Are Key Travel and Keycap Top Shapes Compatible? Three Shapes Considered Through Low-Lift Typing

  • Copied the URL !
Column
About This Article
This column includes the author’s analysis and perspective on keyboard products, market developments, and related topics. While every effort is made to verify factual information, the analysis and evaluation reflect the author’s point of view. It should be read as opinion-based editorial content rather than a product review or news report.

A column.

I once had the chance to discuss preferred key travel with a keyboard designer from overseas.

I generally prefer around 2.8–3.4 mm of key travel.

More than whether a switch is MX-compatible or low-profile, this key travel just feels right to me.

G28PrTBboAAspLuKawamura

Many Kailh Choc V2 switches have 2.8 mm of key travel.
Even among Cherry MX-compatible switches, I prefer shorter travel.
These are what are commonly called “speed switches.”

As we talked, I started thinking about something I’d vaguely felt for some time.

Could there be some kind of affinity between key travel and the shape of the keycap top surface?

To put it another way, I think “typing style” may be what connects the two.

This time, I’ll explore that idea a little further.

Table of Contents

Is Low-Lift Typing Related to Shorter Key Travel?

When typing on a laptop keyboard, don’t many people move to the next key without lifting their fingertips very much?

Sometimes you might slide your fingers while keeping them in contact with the keycaps; other times, you might lift them just slightly and move along a nearly horizontal path.

Here, I’d like to define both as “low-lift typing”.

What caught my attention was the relationship between this finger movement and key travel.

Let’s take a standard CHERRY MX-compatible switch with 4.0 mm of key travel as an example.

If adjacent keys start at the same height, fully pressing one creates a 4.0 mm height difference between its top surface and that of the unpressed key.

With 1.5 mm of key travel, the height difference would be 1.5 mm.

gk stroke step difference

Of course, if you lift your finger off the pressed key and raise it sufficiently before moving to the next one, this height difference does not necessarily become an obstacle.

Still, shorter key travel means a smaller difference between the pressed and resting positions.

If a keyboard makes it easy to type without moving your fingers far up and down, it should also suit a typing style that keeps them on a low path—in other words, low-lift typing.

G28PrTBboAAspLuKawamura

For now, I’ll set aside the actuation point.
The assumption here is that input occurs only when the key bottoms out.

The keycap shape is another factor to consider.

Imagine that the keycap top is very deeply concave.

Depending on the direction you slide your finger, you may need to lift it out of the concavity before moving to the next key.

With a flat keycap top, on the other hand, you can slide straight across.

Many of the scissor-switch mechanisms used in today’s laptops have extremely short key travel, and their keycap top surfaces are almost always flat.

So perhaps the common pairing of short key travel and flat keycaps is about more than just appearance or thinness.

Thinking About Three Keycap Shapes Through the Direction of Finger Movement

I previously wrote an article for PFU’s “HHKB Life,” explaining keycap shapes.

As mentioned there, keycap top surfaces can be broadly divided into three types: flat, cylindrical, and spherical.

gk keytop three surfaces

Flat tops have the familiar level shape seen on keyboards such as Apple’s. Their defining feature is that the top surface’s contours are unlikely to get in the way, no matter which direction you move your fingertips.

Cylindrical tops are exemplified by the Cherry profile. They are curved primarily from side to side.

Spherical tops are found in profiles such as SA. They curve in both the front-to-back and side-to-side directions, giving your fingertips a sense of settling into the center.

In terms of tactile guidance for finger placement, flat tops offer the least, while spherical tops provide the most.

Cylindrical tops fall somewhere in between.

On the other hand, even with spherical tops, a shallow curve might make it possible to combine tactile guidance for finger placement with low-lift typing.

However, I think that may not always be the case, depending on the switches’ key travel.

Flat Tops for Short Travel, Spherical Tops for Long Travel?

Personally, I feel that key travel and keycap top shape have a certain compatibility.

gk keytop stroke hypothesis

With shorter key travel, low-lift typing—moving your fingertips close to the surface—pairs well with flat tops, bringing out their advantages.

With longer travel, you’re more likely to lift your fingertips and land them on the next key.

In that case, the central dip of a spherical top can help you sense where your fingertip is.

As for cylindrical tops, my personal feeling is that, at least when they follow the original Cherry design, their curves are not particularly deep, so they work reasonably well with pretty much any key travel.

G28PrTBboAAspLuKawamura

For that reason, I tend to use keycaps with cylindrical tops.
On the other hand, for a deep, thocky typing sound, I like taller, spherical-top keycaps such as SA, MT3, and KAT.
It’s interesting that there are surprisingly few tall keycaps with flat or cylindrical tops.
Thinking about typing sound too takes me too far down the rabbit hole, so I’ll leave that aside for now.

Seen this way, the three shapes can be arranged from short to long key travel in this order: flat → cylindrical → spherical.

gk keytop stroke hypothesis

Of course, this does not mean one shape is better than another.

In actual typing, fingers both slide and lift, and typing style is not determined by key travel alone.

Even so, the idea that the keycap top is both “the surface you press” and “the surface you touch when moving to the next key” seems meaningful to me.

That said, I don’t want to claim that flat tops are better suited to short key travel.

Personally, I prefer keycap tops that give my fingertips some tactile cues over flat tops.

Reading Earlier Designers’ Thinking Through the Shapes of Their Devices

It’s interesting to look at typewriters and laptops through this lens.

Many older typewriters have round keycaps with raised edges.

91FuvnkyQrL. AC SX679
This is a three-dimensional puzzle shaped like a typewriter. Image via: Amazon

The act of typing a character—in other words, a single keystroke—probably involved more travel than modern typing does.

At that travel distance, low-lift typing may not even have been a concept. People may have tended to target each key precisely and press straight down, and the keytops may have been shaped to resist force applied directly from above.

Laptops, on the other hand, use low-profile switch mechanisms to keep their cases thin, and the combination of short travel and flat keytops has become widespread.

This is a point I’m not entirely sure about. My impression is that the keytops were probably made flat simply because, with a folding design, they would otherwise come into contact with the screen—not because a flat shape made low-lift typing easier.

Still, the low-lift typing style probably emerged as a result of combining this move toward thinner designs with flatter keytops.

Keyboard construction changes how people type, and those typing styles then influence the design of later products. It wouldn’t be surprising if that kind of relationship existed.

Summary: It’s Interesting to Consider Keycap Top Shapes and Key Travel

That’s my column on the relationship between keycap top shapes and key travel.

There are many interacting factors here, and other considerations likely come into play too, such as changes in typing sound caused by shape, switch characteristics like linear or tactile, the actuation point, physical layouts (row-staggered, column-staggered, or ortholinear), and the keyboard’s overall size.

There’s clearly plenty of room for personal preference here, and what you might call a “typing philosophy” probably plays a big role too.

It might be even more interesting if choices of switches and keycap development were based on these kinds of philosophies.

What kind of keycaps and switch travel do you prefer?

  • Original publication date:
  • Last updated:
  • Research method : None (original column)
  • References and sources : None (original column)
  • Conflict of interest : No products provided; monetized links in this article: Yes (Amazon links)

Greenkeysの記事をGoogleで見つけやすく Find Greenkeys More Easily on Google

Google検索の「優先ソース」にGreenkeysを追加します

Add Greenkeys as a Preferred Source on Google

ブランド/企業のご担当者様へ:
製品設計やリリース前のフィードバックに関するご相談は
こちらからお進みいただけます。

For Brands and Manufacturers:
For product design consultation and pre-release feedback,
please contact GreenEchoes Studio.

Share me!
  • Copied the URL !

Avatar of Ryosuke Kawamura Ryosuke Kawamura Greenkeys Editor-in-Chief

Ryosuke Kawamura is the Editor-in-Chief of Greenkeys and the founder of GreenEchoes Studio.

He covers mechanical keyboards, custom keyboards, and input devices through reviews, interviews, hands-on testing, photography, and editorial work. He has reviewed more than 100 products and regularly reports on JIS-layout compatibility and trends in the Japanese keyboard market.

He also founded the Japan Layout Alliance (JLA), an industry collaboration initiative aimed at improving compatibility for Japanese-layout keyboards.

Greenkeys values editorial independence and transparency. Product samples, advertising relationships, and affiliate links are disclosed within each article.

Table of Contents